Surface roughness and phase delay
Thanks for the handy calculator for surface roughness!
Something that the page doesn't mention, is that surface roughness not only increases attenuation, but also slows down wave propagation. This is also a contributing factor to the discrepancy between material DK and design DK (along with material anisotropy).
A good way to model both effects is with a gradient model, which gradually transitions from your bulk material to the surrounding free space using the RMS surface roughness Rq. It works well, but it assumes a fairly predictable statistical distribution of roughness, which frequent irregularities will invalidate.
The brute force, ugly way to get around this is to prototype a whole panel of microstrip filters, each tweaking the nominal geometry slightly (slight elongations or shrink factors applied to resonators, coupling gaps adjusted for over-etch or under-etch slightly) and to measure them all. The best performer's artwork would be filed with config management... and then we'd repeat the process each time the board house changed their process.
(Of course, something else that could mess around with your phase delay is ferromagnetic PCB track plating, like nickel used in ENIG and ENEPIG, which may also cause dispersion and odd resonances... but that's a whole different discussion.)
Thanks for this post! I never considered the effect of surface roughness on propagation delay, but it makes sense. This deserves a new page on Microwaves101.
I personally think we should also start a page on "how printed circuit boards ruined my career".
Sign in or register to add a comment.
Add a Comment
About Our Site
Biological Effects and Applications
Computer Aided Design
Emerging Applications and Technology
Filters and Passives
MMIC and RFIC
Packaging and Materials
Sources and Receivers
Test and Measurement
Multiband power combiner with inputs of unequal magnitude and phase
19-21 GHz phase shifters?
Coax Loss Calculation and Phase
Coax dielectric loss
Terms of Service
Useful Hints and Tips
Created with PlushForums
© 2020 Microwaves 101 Discussion Board